Recently, Figma faced a backlash after it was discovered that their “Make Designs” generative AI tool produced designs that closely resembled Apple’s weather app. This raised concerns about potential legal issues and ethical considerations surrounding the use of AI in design tools. Figma CEO Dylan Field was quick to clarify that the tool was not trained on Figma content or app designs. However, the company’s response to the issue raises questions about the ethics of AI training and design.
In a statement released on their company blog, Figma acknowledged that they did not vet the design systems underlying the Make Designs feature carefully enough. This oversight led to assets in the design system bearing similarities to real-world applications, resulting in the Apple-like mockups generated by the AI tool. Figma took immediate action to remove the problematic assets from the design system and disabled the feature. They are now working on implementing an improved QA process before reinstating Make Designs.
The Role of AI Models in Design Tools
Figma revealed that the AI models powering the Make Designs tool included OpenAI’s GPT-4o and Amazon’s Titan Image Generator G1. These models were fed metadata from carefully curated design systems to generate designs based on user prompts. The use of AI in design tools like Make Designs is intended to assist users in identifying, arranging, and filling out design templates from a design system. However, the incident with the Apple-like mockups raises concerns about the ethical implications of AI-generated designs.
One of the key ethical considerations in the use of AI in design tools is the training data used to develop AI models. Figma commissioned extensive design systems for Make Designs, but the company did not disclose who was involved in creating these systems. The lack of transparency around the training data and the training process raises concerns about the potential biases and ethical implications of AI-generated designs. Users should be aware of how their data is used to train AI models and have the option to opt in or out of allowing Figma to train on their data.
The Future of AI in Design Tools
Despite the controversy surrounding the Make Designs feature, Figma announced other AI tools at their Config event, including a tool that generates text for designs. These features are still available to users, but Figma has outlined their AI training policies to give users the choice to opt in or out of data training. As AI technology continues to advance, it is essential for designers and developers to consider the ethical implications of AI in design tools and prioritize transparency and user consent in AI training processes.
The incident with Figma’s Make Designs tool highlights the importance of ethical considerations in the development and implementation of AI in design tools. Transparency, user consent, and careful vetting of design systems are crucial to ensuring that AI-generated designs are ethical and unbiased. As AI technology becomes more integrated into design tools, it is essential for companies to prioritize ethical practices and user privacy to build trust with their users.
Leave a Reply