As the technological landscape rapidly evolves, the emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) has fundamentally altered the way content creators approach their craft. Substack, a platform for independent writers and newsletter creators, finds itself at the nexus of this transformation. Despite being a frontrunner in the content creation space, Substack has not formally articulated a policy regarding the use of AI for its writers. This absence of guidelines places both opportunities and challenges onto the shoulders of its content producers, who must adapt to a shifting paradigm.
Hamish McKenzie, one of Substack’s co-founders, posits that the generative AI boom represents a profound shift that writers must engage with, irrespective of their views on its implications. He voiced his perspective in a post, stating that opinions on AI’s validity are irrelevant; the reality is that it is infiltrating every facet of content creation. This sentiment echoes throughout the writing community, where many authors recognize the necessity of embracing AI tools, either for convenience or to enhance the quality of their output.
Engaging with various Substack authors reveals a spectrum of attitudes toward AI that center on using it for enhancement rather than replacement. David Skilling, the founder of the Original Football newsletter, exemplifies this view by describing AI as a “substitute editor.” He champions the role of AI in improving productivity, stating, “I proudly use modern tools for productivity in my businesses.” This perspective highlights a significant distinction between AI-generated texts and AI-assisted works, underscoring the idea that AI can complement human creativity rather than usurp it.
In the startup-focused newsletter Spotlight by Xartup, writer Subham Panda elaborates on the team’s use of AI as a tool for curation and content enhancement. The emphasis remains on a human touch, with writers responsible for the narrative’s integrity while using AI to manage operational efficiency. By concentrating on auxiliary tasks such as image generation and information aggregation, authors like Panda position themselves in a collaborative role with technology, ensuring that creativity is still rooted in personal expression.
AI’s utility is not restricted to creative prose; financial writers are increasingly exploring its capabilities as well. Max Avery, from the Strategic Wealth Briefing newsletter, cites his use of AI tools like Hemingway Editor Plus for refining drafts. This application reveals a growing trend among writers, where preliminary thoughts are enhanced through technology, resulting in a polished end product. Financial entrepreneur Josh Belanger also integrates AI, utilizing ChatGPT to fine-tune his newsletter, Belanger Trading. He elaborates on the complexities of financial writing, stressing that AI’s involvement requires careful prompting to mitigate inaccuracies. This hybrid model showcases the necessary collaboration between intuition and machine efficiency, emphasizing the need for human oversight to navigate technical subject matter appropriately.
Interestingly, Substack appears to maintain a comparatively lower volume of AI-generated writing compared to platforms like Medium, which has seen nearly 40% of its published content produced by AI tools. This discrepancy prompts questions about content authenticity and the writing process’s integrity on different platforms. While Substack nurtures a community focused on individual expression and craftsmanship, competitors may prioritize volume and speed, leading to qualitatively diverse outcomes.
As AI continues to reshape the writing landscape, Substack stands at a crossroads where the balance of technology and human creativity must be carefully maintained. For writers on this platform, the choice to integrate AI becomes less a matter of ethical conflict and more a strategic decision that hinges on their personal and professional goals. By embracing AI as an assistive technology rather than a replacement, Substack authors can navigate this new paradigm, ensuring their work remains genuine and impactful even amidst the automated world. The future of writing of all kinds hinges on this crucial balance, where collaboration with AI leads to both efficiency and authenticity in storytelling.
Leave a Reply